The Best 1st Base Glove For You: Our Review 2020

Mitts, or sometimes called first baseman gloves, are a unique tool to help the first baseman in a baseball match. These boys’ job is to catch extremely difficult throws that are not always accurate and therefore, making the design of our first base glove a bit different from other mitts used in the game. Instead of fingers outside of the gloves, the creation of essential first baseman gloves looks almost like mittens and almost shaped like a funnel to allow balls to be caught easily. The best 1st base glove should have additional padding as well since it is added to the glove to reduce the pressure when a hard throw during catching, making a real change when it comes to playing baseball. You should look for gloves with a deep pocket and as comfortable and durable as possible as the first baseman will be the one who catches incredible hard and tricky throws. Therefore, to make their job more comfortable, the gloves have to fit perfectly with the players and be strong enough to support hard throws, so they don’t bend backward.

So, how can you pick the best 1st base glove to optimize your potential during the match? We have compiled a list of products we believe to be the best first base glove for you to compare and pick out which one may be suitable for your game. Read our article down below to find out which best first base gloves are our top picks.

** Below, you will find our detailed reviews of the best 1st base glove, but you can also click these following links to see current prices or read customer reviews on Amazon.

Top Best 1st Base Glove Reviews 2020

No products found.

These first base gloves coming from Wilson’s, an already famous brand in making first base gloves, easily the best first base gloves, in my opinion. Although the price is a bit more than your average first base gloves, its quality reaches beyond that.

Made from pro-stock leather with the outside included Wilson’s very special patent Superskin, a type of lightweight material that helps your gloves to become more durable and robust while still making the grasp and feel of the gloves remain incredibly light for its weight.

On the wrist, there is a Velcro strap to make sure that the gloves stick perfectly to your hand. The additional padding can cut down the brunt of the ball from a hard throw. The product is available for Left Hand Throw and Right Hand Throw.

PROS

  • Made from fine materials
  • Lightweight than the full leather
  • Unique design to optimize the catch and fit perfectly in your hand

CONS

  • Quite expensive
  • Can be stiff for first-time users

No products found.

The signature Nokona Walnut color softball first base mitt is an attractive choice for first base players. This 2020 Nokona Walnut Select Mod-Trap version is an upgraded version of its previous line. The signature Walnut Crunch leather gives the gloves a unique look and stands out from all rest. This leather design is my favorite so far! 

This durability is unmatchable. The product is designed to withstand the strongest and stiffest throw with its stable shape and size, giving you confidence during the game. The design is 13 inches and suitable for adult players. The first base gloves are handcrafted in the USA.

PROS

  • Unique heritage Nokona’s design
  • Stable

CONS

  • Expensive

No products found.

In the Heart of Hide line, Rawlings uses its premium leather to make up this first base glove. The gloves’ strong durability comes from its 5% steer hides. Also, they make these gloves comfortable. The comfort factor is what the player needs the most during a game. Without much air trapped, their hands became breathable. One thing to note from these gloves is that these mittens are 40% broken, and the player should do the rest to make it perfectly shaped in the player’s hand. According to some, the gloves make the inside of your thumb and pinkie become much smoother. The color brown is a classic choice for design as well, in our opinion. Easily, this is the top first base gloves from Rawlings. 

These first base gloves are suitable for players from high school to pros.

PROS

  • Long durability material
  • Comfortable
  • Breathable

CONS

  • Expensive

No products found.

Made according to the information given by 300 professional baseball players, The A2000 was developed catered to these inputs. These 12-inch first base gloves are no exception. Being labeled as a high-end first base glove, the glove’s unique features are what makes your dollar worth.

First, it is worth moving about the durability of these gloves. The gloves allow it to break in easily while still maintaining its durability. Plus, its moisture-wicking technology helps keep the glove’s shape from being torn or worn out. If you want to get your money worth, I highly recommend the Wilson A2000 line.

PROS

  • High-end
  • Durability
  • Nice cream color
  • Moisture-wicking technology

CONS

  • Expensive

No products found.

In the Heart of Hide line, Rawlings uses its premium leather to make up this first base glove. The gloves’ strong durability comes from its 5% steer hides. Also, they make these gloves comfortable. The comfort factor is what the player needs the most during a game. Without much air trapped, their hands became breathable. One thing to note from these gloves is that these mittens are 40% broken, and the player should do the rest to make it perfectly shaped in the player’s hand. According to some, the gloves make the inside of your thumb and pinkie become much smoother. The color brown is a classic choice for design as well, in our opinion. Easily, this is the top first base gloves from Rawlings. 

These first base gloves are suitable for players from high school to pros.

PROS

  • Long durability material
  • Comfortable
  • Breathable

CONS

  • Expensive

No products found.

With a distinctive design of an old, tobacco tan color kind of look, SHOELESS Joe Women’s Fastpitch Softball First Base Gloves is a top choice for first base gloves for its reputation in creating gloves that are high quality and durable. The 12-inch gloves are made from 100% steer hide leather and are hand-cut and sewn individually, accompanied by a single post webbing design. This kind of structure helps the gloves last very long and allows maximum hand protection for the baseman. 

The leather is hand-rubbed with antique ingredients to help soften it; therefore, making it feel comfortable and fit perfectly. The wrist can feel moved flexibly and freely. Plus, it takes less time to break in before using. These gloves are one of the best choices for the best 1st base gloves. And most importantly, it is not that expensive—best for fastpitch players.

PROS

  • 100% steer hide leather
  • Comfortable design
  • Nice color and design
  • Not very expensive compared with its quality

CONS

  • Not optimal for players with bigger hands

No products found.

Although the size is slightly bigger than your standard first base gloves that only range around 12 to 13 inches, the gloves come in 14 inches. The bigger length allows the player to enhance their performance in terms of locking the ball and reaching for tough throws. And for those with slightly small hands, it still provides you with an adjustable wrist strap so you can customize the tightness. 

If you’re looking to improve your performance and technique in terms of finding and catching hard throws and locking the ball sufficiently, the colossal design may work for you! This is the best 1st base gloves for a professional player in my experience.

PROS

  • Premium leather
  • Great for locking the ball
  • Big design works for huge hands

CONS

  • The leather is stiff and rigid when first use
  • Break-in necessary

No products found.

Made with soft and oiled kind of leather, Mizuno’s MVP Prime makes your catch a lot more efficient. Thanks to these qualities, you can take on the brunt of the throw while maintaining a soft, comfortable feel for your hand. The Mizuno’s MVP Prime is the biggest design of first base gloves, in my opinion on the market, about 12.5 inches. The design is unique with its center pocket feature in order to place the ball under the index finger in catches; this allows more control for your hand.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • Comfortable
  • Allowing control

CONS

  • Big
  • Stiffer than other first base gloves
  • It may be harder for young players to break-in

No products found.

Made from premium Japanese kit leather, the Marucci First Base Glove brings superior quality to your baseball playing experience. The gloves are individually handcraft to allow maximum precision to detail. The tension during catches is evenly spread out thanks to the double H-Web design. Therefore, gloves can last longer. 

In the back of the pocket, extra leather is added to reinforce and improve durability as well as protect the laces.

PROS

  • Premium Japanese leather
  • Double H-W design
  • Added leather in the back

CONS

  • Complaints about the worn out after a few plays

No products found.

Another first base glove from Rawlings is the Sandlot Series Baseball Gloves. These gloves are on the market at a more affordable price while including some of the best features that the best 1st base glove can have. The gloves are 12.5 inches, made with full-grain and oiled leather. The design is quite classic as well, with its a black and brown overtone. 

Sometimes, the discomfort you feel while catching a hard throw can be cut down by a padded finger back. However, the gloves are already 90% broken, so it could not be comfortable for your hands like other gloves with higher quality.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • Classic design
  • A padded finger back

CONS

  • May not be as fit as other gloves
  • Not durable after a long time

No products found.

The special first base gloves Blackstone BL3 made from Easton is suitable for all kinds of people who want to play baseball. Easton has long been known for its gloves, standard and straightforward but fits all the needs of first base gloves. With the cowhide leathers made up of the gloves, it is easy to control and gives the gloves almost a lightweight feeling on your hand. This allows optimal comfort when using. 

The impact of the throw can be absorbed by its soft design, including leather-lined padding to create maximum protection and control of the ball. The gloves are 12.75 inches with a dual bat webbing design. In addition to that, it has a short and fast break-in period, making it easier for those who struggle. Also, the durability of the gloves is being ensured as well.

PROS

  • Flexibility maximized with open-back design
  • Standard quality
  • Affordable price
  • Fast break-in period, suitable for both high and low-incomes players

CONS

  • The level of fitting can be questionable
  • May not suitable for players with big hands

No products found.

Wilson Game Ready Soft Pit is another great choice for the youth players. Available in 11.5 inches, the Wilson gloves are the best 1st base gloves for young players since they are made with exclusive Eco-leather to provide softness on the first try by engineering. Also, the full leather construction allows it to break-in easily. 

A piece of leather is placed between the palm liner and the outer shell to enhance the maximum pocket stability. The low profile heel helps the glove to become more flexible and the open up of the palm and pockets make the gloves more forgiving on bad-hop grounders.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • Great for young players
  • Double Palm construction
  • Game-ready and durable
  • Better to break-in

CONS

  • May close early and weirdly
  • Pocket isn’t deep enough

No products found.

Want a give for your children if they suddenly want to play baseball? Now, look no further since the Renegade First Base Mitt is an excellent choice for the youth league. Offering the most reasonable price possible, the first base gloves are a perfect choice for all types of families. Since it is very affordable, no kids shouldn’t be left out of playing their favorite sport. 

The gloves are 11.5 inches in length, a perfect size for young players than other gloves with a bigger size that may only be suitable for adult players. It doesn’t require a break-in period since it is already soft; therefore, the gloves are ready to play. But if you’re looking for a bigger size, it is also available in 12.5 inches. The design of the gloves is made to be lightweight in order to quickly catch difficult throws.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • Suitable for young players
  • Lightweight

CONS

  • Mix reviews about the durability

The Difference Between The 1st Base Glove Compared To Other Gloves In The Pitch

Difference baseball gloves have different designs according to the position of the players. But for first basemen, the creation of the glove needs to be funnel-shaped and mittens lookalike. This is an optimal design for catching the ball whole and accurately. Since the ball sometimes comes with a high velocity, protection for your hand is considered extremely important. The pad will support as well as lessen the pressure so as it will not hurt the players. The design of the first base gloves doesn’t have separated fingers on the outside.

What Should You Consider When Buying Best 1st Base Gloves?

The first base gloves are necessary if you want to play baseball. The first baseman requires a quick reflex and is efficient at scooping the ball from the ground and handling hard throws. Finding suitable, best first base gloves is essential to maximizing the role of the first baseman in the game. So, to weigh out the choices of finding the best first base gloves, you need to read these factors that can affect the quality and the experience of using the gloves.

Sizing

To scoop out the hard throws or stop the balls, the gloves (or mitts) need to be longer in length and have a larger build. The average first baseman’s gloves are between 12 to 13 inches in size. The gloves’ size needs to fit comfortably to the player’s size because any longer or smaller can cause the player to struggle to hold or catch the ball during the game, affecting their ability and the game.

Best 1st base glove

Material

Most of the gloves are made out of leather for durability. The longer the gloves last, the best for the players. And good quality made suitable gloves. The best leather can make your gloves less worn out from being used too much or used during extreme or hazardous weather. For younger players or first-timers, durability may not be the key, but it is quintessential for professional ballplayers. Keep in mind that gloves that are made of the highest quality may be harder to break in. But this is a good thing since the glove is shaped to the player’s hand. And for cheaper gloves, the material used is synthetic; it is certainly ready to use but will not last long.

Padding

Padding is essential for the position of first basemen since it provides extra insulation. If your gloves are made from leather, you don’t have to worry since they already provide extra protection naturally. If your gloves are added with paddings, normally, they will be placed in the palm or heel of the glove position.

Throwing Hand

You need to pick a glove that is OPPOSITE your throw hand. Be sure to double-check before you purchase; they will have two alternatives for right or left hand in the product.

Best 1st base glove

Prices

Normally, you will be expecting more than $150 for a decent pair of first base gloves and $200 or more for higher quality. But hey, stop the frowning, leather can last for many years, and if you’re a professional player, you would want to maximize your performance as much as possible, and the higher quality will be worth your bucks more.

But if you’re short on money, less than $100 is also an acceptable option for newcomers. And for young players, the prices are expected to be around $50 for a decent pair of the best 1st base gloves.

How About The Young Players?

Generally speaking, the gloves will be needed to transition from youth sized gloves like the gloves we mention at the bottom of the list (The Wilson Game Ready or Rawlings Renegade) to the bigger, adult-sized type of gloves. And if your child has a slightly bigger hand, you need exact measurements for youth league gloves that can be too small for them. 

Best 1st base glove

However, keep in mind that another factor that may dictate your child’s kind of glove is the position. You will need bigger gloves for a position in the outfield and smaller ones for the infield. For the particular position of first baseman and catchers, they have a different design with particular mitts.

Keep In Mind

No gloves can fully better your performance. The quality of the gloves doesn’t aggressively change your performance; however, with practices and full consideration on which types of first base gloves work for you, you can improve your performance noticeably! You either can do this by borrowing one from your teammates or coaches to play first; this will make sure that you are suitable for the position of the first baseman as well as to see what’s lacking in the gloves.

Our Tips

  • Leather is not doing good with heat and steam, so keep your leather gloves away.
  • If you stop using the gloves for a long time after the season ends, apply a light layer of glove oil to keep it from drying out. It is advised to add a ball into the glove in order for it not to lose its shape.
  • You can use a flexible tape measure to measure your hand for a glove. Measure from the tip of the index finger to the hell of the glove; it should be located at the wrist. For average: 7 years old is 11.5 inches, 8 to 12 years old is 11.5 to 12 inches, and 14 and more is 12 inches.

How To Break In Your Gloves

Different catching styles will determine different ways you can break in your 1st base glove. Essentially there are two catching styles: single break or double break. You can watch this video to determine which way is the best way to break in your first base mitt.

Here is a video for you to grab more information:

Conclusion: My Top Pick For best 1st base glove

After much consideration, these are our top picks for the best 1st base glove.

1

Best 1st base glove for high-end lines

No products found.

2

Best 1st base glove for a unique design

No products found.

3

BEST FOR comfortableness

No products found.

4

BEST overall

No products found.

5

BEST 1st base glove for female athletes

No products found.

After much comparison between each pair of gloves to select which one is the best 1st base glove for what category, we came up with these ones:

  • For high-end lines, Wilson A2000 Fastpitch Glove Series exceeded our expectations; with its long-lasting durability and finest leather, this glove will be worthy of every buck you spend.
  • I always have a soft spot for beautiful design. Therefore I think the Nokona Walnut Series deserves a place on our overall table. Although receiving mixed reviews, the Nokona first base gloves are still proved to be a worthy purchase for its durability, alongside its heritage design.
  • For comfortableness and being breathable, RawlingsHeart of The Hide Baseball Glove Series is a perfect choice for baseball games.
  • For overall, we pick Wilson A2000 12-Inch SuperSkin Baseball Glove. Engineered and put together by the input of 3000 professional players, no 1st base glove can cater best to the needs of a first baseman.
  • For female athletes, Rawlings Heart of The Hide Fastpitch Softball Glove Series is designed specifically for professional female players since it requires only 35% break-in for the players, and it also comes in a wide range of sizes.
  • Don't forget to share your thoughts about best 1st base glove at the comment box below!

Leave a Comment